Overview
FIRST invites luminaries from many fields to be Competition judges.
These men and women serve as role models to the competitors by their actions and through frequent interactions with the competing FIRST teams
while on-site.
Judges do not participate in referee decisions on the playing field. Judges may not have any affiliation with any team competing.
The judging panel consists of several judges and a Judge Advisor.
The number of judges required depends on the number of teams registered to compete in your regional Competition. Based on 40 teams, a panel of 11 judges plus one Judge Advisor is ideal. FIRST's Regional Manager will work closely with your Judge Coordinator in developing a judge panel, guide
you in the judge recruitment efforts, and answer any questions or concerns that may arise. FIRST's Regional Manager will recruit the Judge Advisor for your regional, and will also recruit
experienced FIRST judges on behalf of FIRST for your Competition.
It is important to have a judging panel that reflects a good balance of veteran and first-time judges, as well as one, which achieves racial, ethnic, gender and age diversity.
The veteran judges serve as mentors for the first-time judges during the event, and guide them through the intense judging process.
FIRST's Regional Manager will recruit the Judge Advisor and veteran judges for your regional panel and will discuss with you the appropriate number of new judges you need to recruit
for your regional Competition. Please note that having too many judges on the panel is detrimental to the judging effort.
Judging is demanding work, very intense, but also very rewarding.
Judges are responsible for their own travel/accommodation expenses and arrangements. Each judge will be given one golf-style FIRST JUDGE shirt to wear during the Competition. Judge attire
is casual, and comfortable shoes are a must! Judges do a lot of walking between the playing field, the pit area, and the judge room!
Judge Coordinator
The planning committee should designate a Judge Coordinator to recruit first-time judges for your regional Competition and to function
as an on-site contact for the judges during the Competition. During the Competition, the Judge Coordinator functions as an assistant to the Judge Advisor. The Coordinator keeps the
Judge Advisor and the panel on schedule throughout each day. This is VERY important. The Coordinator also helps the judges and the Advisor in writing the award scripts each day and
getting them to the Master of Ceremonies each afternoon at the agreed upon time. The Coordinator is on radio communication throughout each day and communicates any changes in playing
schedule/timing to the Advisor and the panel as needed. This person needs to have an outgoing personality, a lot of energy, and strong writing skills (including basic word processing).
The Coordinator keeps the judge panel motivated and spirited throughout each day.
Thursday Night Judge Dinner Meeting
A Thursday night orientation dinner meeting is held the night before the Competition begins. This meeting is mandatory for all judges. At the dinner meeting, the judging panel will
have an opportunity to meet each other, their Judge Advisor, and some FIRST managers. An overview of FIRST, the game, judging responsibilities, awards, and judge schedule will be
discussed. Note: this dinner could be held at the designated VIP hotel or another nearby location. The Event Manager and Regional Manager will
work with your planning committee in identifying a suitable location.
Criteria for Regional Judges
-
Typically, individual maintains an upper management position in his/her company or is a professor/dean at the university level
-
Individual possesses an engineering, technical, or science related background, education or interest
-
Judge candidates should not be affiliated with any university or company, which is sponsoring a team registered to compete in your regional
-
Judge panel should reflect diversity
Judge Biographies
Once a candidate has agreed to become a judge, he/she needs to provide a brief (no longer than 50 words) biographical paragraph, which highlights their career achievements, awards,
affiliations, etc. These biographies may be printed in the regional program, and abbreviated versions may be used by the regional emcee on-site to introduce the judges each morning
during the opening ceremony. Your planning committee's Judge Coordinator should email these biographies to FIRST in keeping with the program book-printing deadline. Typically, this
deadline is in early to mid-December.
Role of the Judge Advisor
The Judge Advisor facilitates the panel discussions and the judging process throughout the event. He/she organizes the judge panel into groups, sets the schedule for the day's judging process, assigns the judging tasks, and writes the awards script. The Advisor does not vote unless absolutely necessary.
FIRST will recruit a Judge Advisor for your regional Competition.
Sample Judge Schedule and Responsibilities
The time commitment required of a judge candidate begins with a Thursday night dinner meeting and runs through the close of
Competition on Saturday late afternoon. It is important that a judge candidate be able to commit to that entire time period. The judge panel starting
time on Friday and Saturday morning is finalized at the Thursday night dinner. A sample itinerary and regional awards is on the following pages. As
the information specifies, travel, transportation, and hotel expenses are not paid for by FIRST.
Planning Timeline Note:
Judge recruitment should begin in September. A final judge panel should be in place by early December. It's always
a good idea to have one extra judge candidate standing by in case of a last minute cancellation from someone on the judging panel. FIRST's Regional
Manager will let your Judge Coordinator know how many judges he/she should recruit for the panel.
Sample Regional Judge Schedule
Thursday
| 6 pm - 8 pm |
Judges Dinner and Meeting |
Friday
| 8 am - 9 am |
Judges Breakfast and Meeting |
| 9 am - 4 pm |
Matches |
| 12 pm - 1 pm |
Judges Lunch and Meeting |
| 4 pm |
Awards |
| 6 pm - 9 pm |
Team Party |
Saturday
| 8 am - 9 am |
Judges Breakfast and Meeting |
| 9 am - 4 pm |
Matches |
| 12 pm - 1 pm |
Judges Lunch and Meeting |
| 4 pm |
Awards |
Regional Judge
Responsibilities
When on-site, judges interview FIRST teams in the Pit Area, as well as watch the Competition
on the playing field.
| Sample Friday Awards |
Sample Saturday Awards |
| Imagery |
#1 Seed ** |
| Leadership in Control |
Highest Rookie Seed** |
| Delphi "Driving Tomorrow's Technology" |
Incredible Play* |
| General Motors Industrial Design |
DaimlerChrysler Team Spirit |
| Motorola Quality |
Johnson & Johnson Sportsmanship |
| Xerox Creativity Award |
Judges' Special Award (1) |
| Judges' Special Award (1) |
Rookie All Star (1) |
| Rookie All-Star (1) |
Regional Finalist ** |
| Rookie All-Star (1) |
Regional Champion** |
* winner determined via team ballot
** winner determined via matches